1 2 Risorse per l'uso professionale Mac 2 Cerca nel sito Contattaci Gallerie Newsletter Forum forum
4 5 ipodnet
logosxbasso  

Eye TV 2.2: full TV control for Mac and iPod
by Settimio Perlini
02-07-2006


The latest version the software from ElGato simplifies the interaction between Mac, iPod and TV using every tool available online and offline to prepare your recordings, planning the vision of your shows. It works smoothly with Elgato devices but also with the one produced by Terratec and Miglia.

We have tested it with Miglia TV Mini and Terratec Hybrid TS to check the full functionality with third party devices.
This section of our test is related only to the software. The phisical devices will be reviewed in the next future.


Eye TV 2.2 is bundled with ElGato and Miglia products and has a special serial number for each product but it's sold also as a stand-alone product to work with Terratec PC version devices.
This solution could be interesting for people that wants to use the peripherals in a multi-platform enviroment.


The software is sold trough Elgato website or the online AppleStore in you nation: in Italy you can buy it clicking on this [sponsored] link at 79,96 VAT included.

This the full list of compatible devices as of today:
Elgato: Elgato EyeTV USB, Elgato EyeTV 200, Elgato EyeTV 300, Elgato EyeTV 310, Elgato EyeTV 400, Elgato EyeTV 410, Elgato EyeTV 500, Elgato EyeTV 610, Elgato EyeTV EZ, Elgato EyeTV for DTT
Miglia: Miglia TVMini, Miglia TVMini HD, Miglia Evolution TV
Plextor: Plextor PX-TV402U, Plextor ConvertX per Mac
Satelco EasyWatch
TerraTec: TerraTec Cinergy T”, TerraTec Hybrid TS, TerraTec Cinergy 400, TerraTec Cinergy 450
Twinhand: TwinhanDTV Alpha DVB-T, TwinhanDTV Alpha MAC.

We have made a step by step review analising every aspect of installation, recoriing, editing and PVR functions of the software. The conclusions follow at the end of the commented gallery.

eyetvb4 eye5 ieyetvb7
^ Our Screenshot gallery uses the Terratec Hybrid since it has the most complex configuration of all the Tuners compatibile with EyeTV, due to it's capacity to receive both analog and digital terrestrial channels. We'll also see also specific commands for Elgato and Miglia products as well. ^ You have to input a serial number related to your specific product in order to make EyeTV work properly. The license can be bought also for products that come only with Windows software. ^ The first step is to connect your tuner to the antenna cable. If you have a home antenna is better to test it with a good signal rather than with the portable antenna bundled with some device.
eyetvb8 eyetvb9 siintoanalogic10
^ The next step is to connect the device to the appropriate I/O port, in this case USB 2.0, with other devices you use PC CARD o Firewire. ^ Now you can autotune the channels (Satellite, Analogic or DTT): in this case the hybrid receiver has 2 options: we choose the analog receiver section first. Select also the country since the channel range can be different from country to country. ^ This is the tuner searching for analog channels.
After this, you choose the search for DTT introducing your country too.
sintodtt11 immagine_26 immagine_25
^ This the DTT tuner searching for Digital Terrestrial channels ^ Boom... there you go... DTT TV tuned ^ And DTT Radio Tuned...
But there are other passages in between...
eyetvb12 eyetva18 buildepg
^ You can choose a TV guide or EPG (electronical Program Guide) based on different services alla around the world: with EyeTV you got a one year subscription that makes you record automatically the right broadcast directly from a web page: the schedules are transferred inside the appropriate EyeTV Windows. ^ You can change the settings on a second time via the preferences panel ^ The software tries to collect the EPG data from the tvtv service but first you have to set up the pairing with same name on tvtv.
tvtvepg eyetva9 generalipodencoding
^ Here's the data collected from tvtv.
The EPG can be viewed and searched, and programs may be scheduled for recording, even when there is no Internet connection or TV signal present.
^ Obviously you can do a manual schedule for your preferred shows also with recurring registration.
^ Let's see other preferences: no need to explain anything but the choice of different compression for iPod exporting: the first is better quality at 320x240, the second can be use for projecting video registrations from an iPod to a TV at a resolution product smaller than 340.000 pixels.
eyetva20 eyetva19 eyetvb14
^ This preference let's you choose where to put your recording, how to extend them e how big is the temporary memory used by the PVR function that let's you forward and backward a live trasmission on the fly. ^ You can jump forward and backward during a live trasmission with custom settings. ^ In the display preferences you can choose the best aspect ratio for your standard CRT TV, monitor or display base also on the original transmission settings
eyetva15 eyetva16 eyetvb21
^ You can choose also the best way to deinterlace the signal based on the quality of the transmission and the power of your Mac. Each choice is well documented. ^ The output can be directed to the normal stereo plug of your mac or to the multichannel digital audio output if you have a recent G5 or Mac Intel computer with opticat output. ^ In the devices tab you can check ther current firmware version of your device
eyetvb20 immagine_18 encoding15
^ This tab reveals the quality and the strenght of the signal from antenna: in hybrid devices you can check both tha analog and the digital input at your choice ^ As you can use different receivers from different brands the encoding capabilities may vary depending on the analog or digital tuner and... ^ ... if you have an analog input both from the tuner or the A/V input (if your device has one) you can setup a Recording quality that depends on:
- The power of your Mac (double G4, G5 or Core Duo processors and a high speed of the processor help a lot)
- The presence of an hardware encoder (i.e. tha MPEG2, MPEG4, Divx encoding chip that is built in some Miglia, Elgato, third party devices)
eyetvb16 eyetvb19 eyetva17
^ In the analog input you can choose also the "live" quality to adapt the reception to the power of your Mac: if the processor speed is low (such as 500 Mhz G4) you chan choose a lower resolution avoiding to loose frames otherwise you can choose for the mid or highest quality (in the PAL standards). ^ If the analog receiver has encondig capabilities onboard you have a wider choice on the fly compression: this is the list of available direct encodigs of a Miglia Device, even with a low power Mac. ^ The presence of an internal encoder can be disabled on some models (EZ TV 250, Terratec Cinergy 800/850) so you can get near to zero latency or "Game mode": the best for connecting you game console to your Mac screen
eyetvb22 eyetva6 eyetva7
^ If the receiver works with digital signal there's no possibility of choice in encoding (see the difference on the analog side of this hybrid device) since the size and the bitrate are the same of the streamed original. ^ After al these settings let's look at the "EyeTV programs" window: here you can see the recording (more later), Schedule and Program Guide but let's look at the channels: here you can find the the DTT ones, on a hybrid device you have to switch manually from the digital to the analog reception to see the analog channels under the "Channels" voice... but there's a trick ^ You can add (via the big "+" button) a favourites folder that collects analog and digital channels (you can also build up different favourites such as "Sport", "Movies" and so on) so that you don't have to switch manually from one mode to another.
In this picture you can see the differente information for each channel: for DTT (o DVB-S) you get also the provider (or the boquet). You can choose also if the EPG is based on tvtv or the DTT (or DVB-S) provider.
See the remote command that shows "aed" list, the same name of our "hybrid" favourite
eyetva23 eyetvbest eyetva26
^ Obviously you can also create favourites with your recordings and classify movies, telefilms, sport and so on... The size of te preview can be set with slider in the bottom right corner. ^ Here the "virtual" remote: you can see the channel list, the input (in this case we use a S-video from a Hybrid receiver) the timer and the timeline that shows if you are live or seein a previous part of the recorded material.
The red led over "eyetv" shows that you are in recording mode.
You can pause fast forward and forward, back forward and change volume of the playback.
These commands are available on the original EyeTV command (that comes with Elgato and Miglia products) or on the remotes from Terratec or other third parties.
^ If you press down and up arrow when the remote is active you can navigate trough the list of available channels (even in hybrid mode if you have set up a favourite as we showed before)
eyetva25 eyetva43 eyetva8
^ You can choose the standard list or the favourites directly on the on screen remote ^ If you use your mouse you can use the right button o control-click to open a contestual menu that allows you to choose between aspec ratio, audio channels and output and screensize.
Most of this commands are available trough a combination of keys... we'll see it later navigating trough the main menu.
^ As we have seen you can record just pushing on a button, you can schedule the events via the EPG or external service or you can manually set the recording with date, time, duration, repeats, channel and the ability to create a version for iPod just after the recording (after which iTunes will start and sync with your iPod) so when your back to your computer you have also a "mobile" version of your recordings.
You can do the same with audio recordings building your own podcasts.
eyetva10 agg eyetva12
^ Here the sinthetic information on a sample scheduled recording. ^ If you had used TitanTV o tvtv you could have obtained a lot of more useful details such as director, charachters, plot, year of production and so on...
You can add your own data too because The information can be edited later.

^ Be shure to not overlap your recordings...
eyetva11 eyetva41 eyetva33
^ ... anyway EyeTV is smart enough to give you some advice.... ^ Here's a list of the recordings: in this window you can see info, play, toast and iPod buttons on the top such as "+" button, the free left space and the size of the preview.

The “Backup” command in the Action menu (upper left) can be used to back up the complete archive or a selected set of recordings. This feature requires Roxio Toast 7 Titanium.
^ Let's start a navigation trough menus.
You can add playlist and favorite, open live window and quicktime movies.
When you choose Show Program Info and Stream Info...
eyetva38 eyetvaviewmenu eyetva28
^ ... you get all the data about the current program (at the bottom of the window) and the data about the streaming (at the upper right) with video and audio bitrate and codec used ^ This is the view menu that gives you also access to the Teletext options if your channel has this feature. It's not easy to navigate among pages but you can use the "real" remote control color buttons. Closed caption or subtitles are available.
The latest voice allows you to open the Editor windows when you're accessing a recording. (see further on this matter)
^ This is the audio control window: if the stream has more than one audio/language channel you can choose your preferred one. You can also redirect the sound trough you multichannel audio system if your Mac has a digital audio output (on board like the Mac-Intels or added via an USB board like the Sonica from M-Audio)
eyetva29 eyetva34 eyetva30
^ This menu controls the PVR side of EyeTV: you can choose how to move inside the recordings, fast forward and backward, loop and go to live o recorded pieces. You can activate the recordings also by this menu and, whats more important you can select the input: Tuner, composite video o S-Video. Too bad you can't choose beetwen the analog or digitali side of an hybrid tuner but you have the "favourite" trick we showed before. ^ You can choose the scan rate of accelerated movement trough the recording even at a blazing 32X speed! ^ This menu gives you direct access to the windows and control their position and size.
eyetva31 eyetvaeye eye222
^ The last one gives you help trough the offline guide (in French, German, English and Japanese) or trough Elgato support pages online (english).
What's new is the EyeTV VHS assistant that helps you with the entire process of digitizing your videotape, right through to creating a DVD.

The VHS Assistant shows you how to connect the video recorder's outputs, play back the tape, and record it into EyeTV's Archive. From there you can choose to export the file to your iPod, leave it in your EyeTV Archive, or burn a DVD using Roxio's Toast 7 Titanium or iDVD.
The usual setup assistant launches the setup configuration we have seen at the start of this review.
^ If you have an hi-speed two processor G4, G5, or Mac with Intel Core Duo you are able to import from the AV input at full PAL resolution and without the need of a device with an embedded MPEG2 processor (like EyeTV 200, 250, Miglia Evolution etc.)
This recording was done with a MacBook and Cinergy Hybrid TS.
With no embedded Mpeg2 compression and with a slow Mac (single g4 processor) you can record at VideoCD bitrate and resolution.
^ Once recorded, the movie is placed inside the into the "Documents" folder can be read by EyeTV or VLC o exported to iPod or other mobile devices (also cell phones with 3GPP) in any video format you want.
EyeTV can export multiple recordings as a batch. It exports one recording after
another.
Select “Show in Finder” from the Action menu to select the recording in a Finder window.
A double-click on an EyeTV recording document in
Finder will start playback of that recording in EyeTV.
eyetva3 eyetva4 toastit
^ The editing of the clips couldn't be easier: you choose the recording press Control-E and there you go: you have access at the whole recording a with the marker on the center bottom you can decide what pieces need to be erased (before and after the recording, advertising and so on...).
This Invert Markers command, in the editor's action menu, inverts the sense of
the edit markers; instead of marking a sequence, you mark the rest of the show.
The timeline can be fine tuned with more precise access to the frames by clicking on the "fine" button at the left bottom of the window
You can also save a part of the clip as a new recording or export the clip.
If you click on "compact" the recording will be shortened to it's final lenght.
^ Here's how EyeTV shows the clippings of your recordings: choose compact and here you go!

The archive can be exported to any format supported by QuickTime with all its' multimedia extensions (also DiVX if you need it and have the appropriate encoders).
EyeTV offers intelligent choices of
export format for further processing of recordings in applications such as iMovie, iMovie HD, iDVD or
DVD Studio Pro, burning with Toast, use of shows on the iPod and so on. EyeTV analyzes the recording
and chooses the optimum export format. Users can also choose their own export settings.
^ Once recorded you can put directly on DVD you shows, personal movies or whatever directly with Toast by Roxio: see the icon in the EyeTV stripe on top of the window.
You can "toast" several recordings at once and build up a menu for easy access to each one.

As we said in the gallery, most of the commands are replicated in the standard size remote control you get with devices like Miglia and Terratec and most of them have a keyboard counterpart that you can easily manage with a wireless keyboard in you living room.
Futhermore EyeTV is at the center of developers' attention and you can find many applications that allows to control EyeTV remotely from other computer, via a dashboard widget o inside a "media center" application.

The access to all these capabilities may be still sometimes confusing for the newcomers but EyeTV is becoming, version after version, more flexiblle and easy to use.

The support of hybrid tuners and the use of favourites for recording and channels are a really step forward, together with the complete automated managing of audio-video recordings for iPod.

Thank to the recurring schedules and the reception of DVB radio you can build your own radio Podcast even if the broadcaster hasn't set one.

In out test we also used the super-video input of Terratec Hybrid for recording a Google Map itinerary projected trough the super-video exit of a PowerBook and the recording of trailer from a "Shrek 2" DVD: providing you have a fast Mac like any of the new ones with Duo Core Intel processor, you can achieve a good DVD quality recording at full PAL resolution without relevant artifacts (if you keep the bitrate high) and you can use this video on iPod, iMovie or DVD: the perfect integration with iLife.

Even more, if you got a "media extender" like Elgato EyeHome or a third party uPnP device you can easily access all your EyeTV recordings remotely from another room.

Pros
A lot of features for a grown up software, complete integration of iPod inside the TV-Radio pipeline, easy editing of recordings. It's almost a "standard" for TV on Mac given the the third party software that widens its use to a complete media center resource.

Cons
Some features are buried inside menus or action buttons. The remote control should work also with Mac system commands (controlling Front Row, iTunes, the cursor and so on...). Analog channels with Hybrid Terratec receiver come with mono audio.

Conclusions
If you got a Terratec or other third party device that is supported by EyeTV, go buy it: it gives you a total control of TV inside your Mac. If you have a powerful Mac and the receiver has a video input you can also use it to manage your VHS conversion or recording lessons from other computers.
The price seems a little bit high but in most cases EyeTV is bundled like with Miglia, Elgato recorder and with Terratec you got a versatile multiplatform device.

Where:
you can donwload the latest version of EyeTV 2.x from Elgato web site

How Much?
EyeTV 2.x is free for Miglia and Elgato recent buyers and costs 79.95 Euro (VAT included) for other devices. You can buy directly from Elgato o from AppleStore.
AppleStore Italy sells EyeTV on this page.

P.S.
We are preparing and Italian version of this review. Check this page in the next few days.

 

  • Notizie a tema le trovi su:
  • Macity
  • MacProf
  • IlmioMac
  • Aggiornamac
  • iPodnet
  • Fotodigi
  • Palmipede
  • <%4DEXECUTE:exeres:=WN_ArticleCat([WNArticles]Code;'macity';'
    ';true)%>
  • <%4DEXECUTE:exeres:=WN_ArticleCat([WNArticles]Code;'macprof';'
    ';true)%>
  • <%4DEXECUTE:exeres:=WN_ArticleCat([WNArticles]Code;'ilmiomac';'
    ';true)%>
  • <%4DEXECUTE:exeres:=WN_ArticleCat([WNArticles]Code;'aggiornamac';'
    ';true)%>
  • <%4DEXECUTE:exeres:=WN_ArticleCat([WNArticles]Code;'ipodnet';'
    ';true)%>
  • <%4DEXECUTE:exeres:=WN_ArticleCat([WNArticles]Code;'fotodigi';'
    ';true)%>
  • <%4DEXECUTE:exeres:=WN_ArticleCat([WNArticles]Code;'palmipede';'
    ';true)%>